The Maine Public Broadcasting Network
Listen Live
Classical 24
Who Pays to Transmit Renewable Energy? NE States Divided

A rift has developed among New England states over who should pay for transmission lines needed to carry electricity from renewable energy projects. As Vermont Public Radio's John Dillon reports, the issue is whether ratepayers across the region should foot the bill for power lines needed for southern New England.

Related Media
NE States at Odds over Energy Transmission Listen

Southern New England - in particular Massachusetts and Connecticut - needs more renewable generation to meet their clean-energy mandates. But the supply to meet that demand is mostly in the north - wind power from the mountains of Maine, or hydroelectricity from vast reservoirs in Quebec.

Kerrick Johnson is vice president of the Vermont Electric Power Company, which operates the statewide grid. He says the region is already looking at more than $4 billion worth of new transmission, and that's before the projects needed for renewable energy are added in.

"We start from a position that those who stand to benefit from a transmission project in service of their public policy goals and needs, that they should fund the project," Johnson says.

Johnson is worried about the impact on electric rates if the new projects are built. He points out that new transmission lines to carry electricity to the south would run through states that most likely don't need the power.

"The problem is, what are you paying for?" Johnson says. "If there is a 150-mile transmission line running from extreme northern Maine to move wind power down to Massachusetts or southern Connecticut, we don't know that that would benefit Vermont to a great degree."

The debate over who pays has centered on the concept of socializing costs. That's the idea that all ratepayers should share the expense of projects that benefit society and the region as a whole. The cost of lines deemed necessary to keep the grid running reliably are now spread out across the region.

Proponents of socializing the cost of projects needed to meet a particular state's renewable energy targets say the same logic should apply.

New England states are split on the issue. Opposing the automatic cost sharing for the new power lines are Vermont, New Hampshire and Rhode Island. Officials from Massachusetts, Connecticut and Maine are in favor.

Barbara Kates-Garnick is undersecretary for energy for Massachusetts. She says all the New England states should help pay, because the benefits, such as reaching greenhouse gas reduction goals, are shared regionally.

"It's an easier way to give a signal to the marketplace, in many respects, by having an allocation plan that is regional," Kates-Garnick says.

Vermont officials question whether the regional cost-sharing system is fair for consumers. Chris Recchia is commissioner of the Department of Public Service, which represents Vermont ratepayers. He says transmission projects - and how costs should be shared - need to be evaluated on a case-by-case basis.

"There are transmission organizations that are voting on this that really make all their all their money by building transmission," Recchia says. "Our concerns with the socialized formula is that projects will come out of the woodwork that nobody thought of before, and that given a different cost structure might not be put forward."

The proposal being debated in New England is to share 70 percent of a project's cost regionally, with 30 percent borne by ratepayers in the state that would use the power. The question will ultimately be decided by federal regulators.


Become a Fan of the NEW MPBNNews Facebook page. Get news, updates and unique content to share and discuss:

Recommended by our audience on Facebook:
Copyright © 2015 Maine Public Broadcasting Network. All rights reserved.